The Hypocrisy of Beyonce and the Impossibly Skinny Disney Princess

A couple of weeks ago, I tuned into the Billboard Music Awards ceremony for a little while. During the ceremony they were honoring Beyonce for her lifetime musical achievements, showing people talking about her and her legacy. One thing that these talking heads were saying was about how great an influence she was for females around the globe. Now, I am not entirely familiar with Beyonce’s catalog of work, but this seemed like a bit of a stretch to me. I know that 2 of her hits: “Irreplaceable” and “All the Single Ladies” both lyrically declare some sort of independence from men, a theme which I am sure has been helpful to some women (although let’s be honest, Beyonce did not write either of these songs and was dating Jay-Z when both were at the height of their popularity), but I can’t think of any of her songs being particularly feminist or even pro-women.

The true problem I had with the entire spectacle was that when Beyonce came out to sing one of her new singles “Run the World (Girls)”. This song is all about how men have had their chance to run the world and it is now time to for women to run it. Now this is a sentiment that I agree with. Women’s opinions and views have been neglected for years in America and their certainly should be more women in power positions. However, Beyonce’s hit really just takes all the chauvinism found within male lead hip-hop and changes it into a female chauvinism. She brags about women having money and running the club and “endless power”. The chorus spills out:

“My persuasion can build a nation
Endless power
Our love we can devour
You’ll do anything for me”

Rather trying to empower women, she almost seems to be teaching women to use seduction to manipulate their way into power. These lyrics accompanied with the performance of the song certainly make it seem so. Her outfit was of the typical shining, midriff baring, mini-skirt worn by most pop stars. These things combined really does nothing to bring women into any sort of real power position whatsoever, but rather furthers the image that women are no more than pretty faces and should count for nothing more than sex appeal. Females who declare that women are on an equal level with men, yet flaunt their perfect bodies around are simply using the oldest trick in the book to gain attention, one used by nearly every single advertising agency: sex appeal. There is a hypocrisy that exists within pop culture, especially with those celebrities who desire to be “role models” to all their tween fans, but still dress in barely there outfits and have sensual dance routines.

Even Lady Gaga, who declares that all were “born this way”, a message saying you do not have to worry about who you are or what you look like and that you should be perfectly content with it has a perfectly skinny body that she chooses to show off in her photoshoots and music videos. I suppose the argument could be made that they are simply confident in themselves and thus want to show off proudly, but when your body is “perfect” like most who make it in that industry, are you truly going to be an aid to empowering the countless girls who are scared to death that they look ugly? Or are too fat? Or aren’t pretty enough? Is this not part of the reason for why diseases like anorexia or bulimia develop? Or why sexuality is given up at such an early age?

The television show The Biggest Loser ran an ad a few weeks ago about its season finale. It showcased all the weight lost throughout the competition and worked its way through all the season’s most touching moments. In the background the song “Just the Way You Are” played triumphantly a seemingly perfect fit to wrap up the show. But, as my brother pointed out to me, this is the exact opposite of what should be playing for this TV show. The song is all about singer Bruno Mars loving a girl just the way she is. This means no change. Exactly. At this moment. How she is. The TV show on the other hand, is all about changing who you are by developing better exercise and eating patterns. While this is overall a good thing (except for maybe the part where they do the makeovers), you are giving the wrong impression by stating “just the way you are”, because their motivation was based on discontentment with the way they were (albeit probably healthy discontentment).

That song, in and of itself, does seem to deliver a good message, but if you watch the music video, you will see that really he is singing to a gorgeous woman who is perfectly dressed and made up. This makes the song lose its merit. He loves her just the way she is, well at least when she looks perfect… If the video had shown him singing to someone who is not the ideal image of beauty within our society, then it would truly make the song meaningful. Instead, it just serves as a song to butter up women’s hearts as Bruno Mars does so well.

My final complaint when it comes to women’s body image and the hypocrisy of “role models” is aimed at Disney. Although Disney has done a decent job of making it princesses multi-racial, it has not done anything to vary their body types. Each and every Disney princess has the same body type, all having unimaginably skinny waists. Some even wear the midriff baring outfits we discussed earlier. I do not know how much this affects women, but I imagine it has got to have some effect that as a little girl there is a 95% chance you will not look like the princess you adore; even if subconsciously. Disney, have you ever thought of making a bigger girl your new princess image? Or would that not sell?

This whole thing reminds me of the image of rich people sitting around at a fancy dinner discussing what to do about poverty. While they may have a good heart, they are missing the point. These celebrities, especially those who claim to want to empower women and make them feel special are all doing it from the place of having both riches and the perfect body. Sure they may have worked hard to get there, but it sets a standard that is nearly impossible to replicate, leading most who try to end in failure. We need role models who will stand up and lead by example, who will say that you do not have to have the riches, glory, hotness, and fame to be special and that you truly are “amazing, just the way you are”.

Author’s Note: These are mere observations, I do not fully understand what it is like to be a girl and what body image is like for women, but hope to understand this fuller and better in order to create true equality for men and women.

Advertisements
This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to The Hypocrisy of Beyonce and the Impossibly Skinny Disney Princess

  1. Tamara says:

    Barneys collaborated with Disney to take their characters into a realistic fashion world for their “Electric Holiday” campaign, set to debut at their Madison Avenue flagship store on November 14, 2012. Our favorite animated characters have ditched their signature garments for high-end clothing to wear down the runway. Mickey Mouse will be dressed in Balenciaga, Minnie Mouse in Lanvin, Goofy in Balmain, Daisy Duck in Dolce & Gabbana, Snow White in Nina Ricci, Cruella de Vil in Rick Owens, and Princess Tiana in Proenza Schouler.

    Due to the outlandish and over the top display, the characters’ bodies look absurd and creepy. It’s making old, standard, and beloved characters enforce the idea that if you aren’t stick skinny, then you are not acceptable. Shame on Disney for allowing this to happen and sending a message to young and impressionable children all over the globe that if your not thin, your not beautiful!

    We urge Disney to put a stop to this and ask that if Barney’s is going to use the characters, they use them as they were drawn….without change!

    Article: http://shine.yahoo.com/fashion/minnie-mouse-daisy-duck-whittled-down-barney-8217-172800382.html

  2. Helen Marie says:

    Agreeing with almost every point you made since these are all details of pop culture that I have myself noticed and argued about with others, I have to raise the question of, referring to your words “Disney, have you ever thought of making a bigger girl your new princess image? Or would that not sell?”, wouldn’t you agree that would popular children shows start starring chubbier images of cartoon children the message would then turn into a passive acceptance of obesity in children? I agree that most of the princesses are tiny and I remember (Ariel especially) how small her waste was at times that it made her head look way too large for her body. Also, notice that most villains or characters that are meant to produce negative outcomes are drawn with large menacing bodies, or if not the villain, the chubbier characters are the ones bringing the humor to the story. In other words, fat people are either evil or something to laugh at. There should definitely be some sort of medium, and I’m sure if I looked closely (I can’t say that I have watched every Disney production ever made) there are characters of relatively normal sizes that do play positive roles (Lilo & Stitch?)
    Anyway, finally the other question I would love to hear your opinion on: Would a poor, unknown, ugly woman with no influence to speak of reach enough people with her feminist views to make a real change in our culture or society? Is there something wrong with being a strong beautiful woman unafraid to show off the work put into “perfecting” her body, whatever her idea of perfect is, AND attempt to use that feminine power to empower other women? To encourage women everywhere to strive for bettering themselves, whether it be physically (the message of their videos) or mentally/emotionally (the message in their lyrics); maybe, in our judgmental society, it is necessary to mold oneself into the image the public will devour eagerly, as ugly as it may be, to gain enough fame and be able to do something about it. However, I do agree with the foundational theme of the pop-star hypocritical facade that you present, completely. Most especially with Beyonce, honestly? I think she’s doing more harm than good. She sends out these powerful messages encouraging women to be confident in their curves, YET all of her ads in magazines or whatever she’s in, are photo shopped to an incredulous point. Sending the message “its okay to have curves, as long as those curves are perfectly shaped with no signs of undesirable details like for example, cellulite (that goes hand in hand with big curves being that curves are fat in aesthetic places)” How dare you Beyonce?! I’d love to hear your thoughts

    Thanks,
    Helen Marie

    • Thanks Helen for your comment!

      I wrote a couple of paragraphs responding and then it magically got deleted so I will do my best to respond to what you said and rehash everything I wrote already!

      I don’t know if having an obese princess or character would be promoting obesity, in the same way I don’t think that having extremely skinny figures promotes healthy eating and exercise patterns. Sure obesity is a huge problem today, but it is a problem even with all the skinny images that we are bombarded with. Having bigger girls on our television wouldn’t damage how people live any more than the current images do now (because they way the current standard is has got to increase the amount of eating disorders there are).

      I guess I want to see a wide range of figures on our televisions and in our magazines portraying what is reality. Some people are bigger and some people are really skinny. And there are lots of people in between! I wish there were examples so nobody feels as if they are substandard or not beautiful for looking a certain way.
      I think that what you say about bigger characters usually being the comic relief or villainous is certainly part of the problem.

      To answer your last question, I don’t think there is anything wrong with someone who has worked hard to stay in shape trying to promote female empowerment (or anything of the sort); I wish there were more examples of people who don’t look perfect being recognized. If Lady Gaga brings hope to people out there, I think that is great (in a way at least), but her images of sexuality seem to be no different than Britney Spears or any Playboy model.

      On a more hopeful note, I love what people like Tina Fey, Amy Poehler, and Aubrey Plaza are doing for women. They stand out not just for their looks, but for their intellect, wit, and the fact that they are all hilarious. I don’t think that they are being thrown into any box either.

      Here is a quote from Plaza in an interview with Elle Magazine
      “ELLE: Darius has a deadpan line, where she accuses Jake Johnson’s character of “dangling my vagina out there like bait.” How do you feel about being a sex symbol?

      Aubrey Plaza: I don’t have much to show, in that sense. Tina Fey is one of my heroes. She once did an interview, or something that I read, where she was like, “Never do Maxim, ever. I will never do it, and it’s not good for girls.” I don’t want to put words in her mouth and I forget what it was exactly, but that stuck in my head, because I’ve been asked to do Maxim before.”

      It’s not much, but maybe it’s a sign that the this perception is slowly evolving…

      Thanks again for your thoughts!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s